The History of Quality in Health Care, 1860 to 1960: An Introduction (101) cover with a chain from Nightingale and Codman to standardization and the Joint Commission

The History of Quality in Health Care, 1860 to 1960: An Introduction (101)

In brief: Measuring, comparing and standardising health care is far older than modern quality improvement. Florence Nightingale built polar area graphs on the mortality rates of British soldiers during the Crimean War, and her statistical graphs helped drive hospital reform (Magnello, 2012); Ernest Amory Codman (1869 to 1940) (Kaska & Weinstein, 1998) recorded surgical complications to judge a surgeon’s ability and a hospital’s efficiency, an idea his colleagues did not welcome (Dervishaj et al., 2015). Their ideas live on in outcome databases (Hines et al., 2020) and surgical audit, yet early followers found them hard to put into practice (Spiegelhalter, 1999).

The history of quality in health care, 1860 to 1960: an introduction (101)

This guide is built on 86 records (79 articles and 7 reviews) from the Web of Science Core Collection, published from 1982 to 2026. It covers the century from 1860 to 1960: Nightingale’s statistics, Codman’s end-result idea, Flexner’s survey of medical education, the American College of Surgeons, the Joint Commission and early audit. Later developments, such as Donabedian’s work and the patient safety movement, appear briefly and are labelled as later. Many sources are historical essays, so their claims are presented as the authors’ accounts.

Try it yourself: Put the milestones of early quality work in order, guess which pioneer or institution an idea belongs to, and match historical ideas to their modern counterparts.
Open the interactive module: Quality History Lab

Learning objectives

By the end of this guide you should be able to:

  1. Describe the ideas of Nightingale, Codman and Flexner and the institutions that grew around them, as the sources state them.
  2. Distinguish quality of care from patient safety, the end-result idea, hospital standardization, accreditation, medical audit, mortality statistics, quality assurance and quality improvement.
  3. Trace how early methods connect to later quality improvement.
  4. Evaluate historical accounts critically, recognising heroic narratives, myths and contested credit.
  5. Apply historical lessons to the work of a quality manager today.

Key concepts

  • Quality of care. A changing notion: in two mid-nineteenth-century day nurseries it meant saving children’s lives (Prochner, 1996); a later reading ties Donabedian’s concept to disputes over medical autonomy (Gasparini et al., 2026).
  • End-result idea. Codman’s practice of recording and analysing surgical complications to judge surgeons and hospitals (Dervishaj et al., 2015).
  • Uniform surgical statistics. Nightingale’s suggestion that began an “epidemiological” approach to comparing surgical outcomes (Spiegelhalter, 1999).
  • Hospital standardization and accreditation. Accreditation in its earliest iterations aimed at a minimum standard of care and now sets standards for high-quality care (Russell & Ko, 2023); one review lists defining minimum standards for hospital accreditation among undated advances in quality (Hines et al., 2020).
  • Medical audit. Examining and comparing outcomes, statistically or through honest appraisal of errors (Spiegelhalter, 1999).
  • Quality assurance and quality improvement. Retrospective review of individual events against clinical criteria, which in the later Medicare programme gave way to proactive improvement (Bhatia et al., 2000; Weinmann, 1998); improvement means measuring performance and implementing change (Colton, 2000).
  • Patient safety. A term whose modern public usage, according to a retrospective on the Anesthesia Patient Safety Foundation (created in 1985), was coined by the foundation’s founders (Eichhorn, 2012).

Contents

  • How this guide was produced
  • Introduction: why the history of quality matters
  • History and development, 1860 to 1960
  • Definitions of quality in the historical literature
  • Distinguishing quality of care from neighbouring concepts
  • Pioneers and their ideas
  • Institutions and programmes
  • Methods that emerged and their later descendants
  • Historiography: myths, contested credit and re-readings
  • Themes and bibliometric profile
  • The history of quality in Türkiye
  • Debates and contradictions in the literature
  • Research gaps and agenda
  • Implications for practice today
  • Summary, discussion questions, further reading and glossary
  • Frequently asked questions and references

How this guide was produced

Database and date. Web of Science Core Collection, Advanced Search, 18 November 2026; no language or year limits; articles and reviews.

Query (verbatim). (TI=(histor* OR "nineteenth century" OR "twentieth century" OR "19th century" OR "20th century" OR pioneer* OR origin* OR legacy OR evolution) AND TI=("quality improvement" OR "quality assurance" OR "quality of care" OR "quality of medical care" OR "health care quality" OR "healthcare quality" OR "quality in health*" OR "patient safety" OR accreditation OR "hospital standard*" OR "medical audit" OR "clinical audit" OR "end result*" OR "hospital standardization") OR TI=(Codman OR Nightingale OR Flexner OR Shewhart OR Donabedian) AND TI=(quality OR safety OR "end result*" OR standard* OR statistic* OR reform OR audit OR outcome*)) AND DT=("Article" OR "Review")

Search development. Two title routes: a historical term with a quality or safety term, or a pioneer’s name with a quality, safety, statistics, reform, audit or outcome term. A broader first version returned 2148 records, with many clinical uses of “history”; the final version returned 378.

Criteria. Included: records that substantively address the history of quality and safety in health care, especially 1860 to 1960, or how later developments built on it. Excluded: contemporary studies without historical content; protocols; unrelated records (for example Nightingale only as a nursing theorist); editorials without substance.

Flow. See Figure 1: 378 identified, 4 duplicates removed, no retracted publications, 374 screened, 288 excluded (154 contemporary quality or safety studies without historical content; 133 unrelated records; 1 protocol without results), 86 included (79 articles and 7 reviews, published 1982 to 2026).

Screening and extraction. AI-assisted screeners applied the criteria to titles and abstracts; the lead reviewer resolved 2 unsure records (both excluded). Evidence was extracted from the titles and abstracts of all 86 records into a structured template. 35 records have no abstract and are cited only for what their titles state.

Limitations. Single database; title search; abstract-level reading without full-text checks or quality appraisal; AI-assisted screening; the English-language and journal bias of Web of Science, which misses most book-length history. Claims are reported as the authors’ accounts, and dates only where a title or abstract states them.

Records identifiedWeb of Science Core Collection, 18 Nov 2026n = 3784 duplicates removed0 retracted publicationsRecords screenedtitle and abstract, AI-assisted screenersn = 374Excluded, n = 288154 contemporary quality orsafety studies withouthistorical content133 unrelated records1 protocol without resultsIncludes 2 unsure records resolvedby the lead reviewer (both excluded)Codes E1, E3 and E2Records includedn = 8679 articles and 7 reviewspublished 1982 to 2026Evidence was then extracted from thetitles and abstracts of all 86 recordsinto a structured template (people,institutions, milestones, methods, legacy,historiography, debates, gaps, Türkiye);35 records have no abstract
Figure 1. Selection of records for this guide. Counts come from the Web of Science export and the screening log.

Introduction: why the history of quality matters

Who is harmed in hospitals, and why? How can doctors and hospitals be compared fairly? Who sets standards, and who checks them? Authors in this corpus return to the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries because they find these questions there. One notes that today’s concern about quality closely resembles the problems of Nightingale’s world 150 years earlier (Meyer & Bishop, 2007); another locates the origin of evidence-based medicine in Codman’s end-result idea (Kaska & Weinstein, 1998).

History is also practical. Many improvement initiatives tackle outcomes rooted in past policy and practice where organisational memory may be lost, and knowing that past can show which changes lasted and which problems never moved (Creese et al., 2026). Quality improvement is described as having multiple origins in systems engineering, quantitative analysis and organisational behaviour (Colton, 2000). The literature is scattered across specialties, with histories of quality assurance in clinical laboratories (Dorsey, 1989) and cardiac surgery (Kalmar, 1990) and of quality improvement in spinal surgery (Hines et al., 2020) and paediatric urology (O’Kelly et al., 2019); older general histories of quality assurance and peer review survive in the corpus only as titles (Fine & Meyer, 1983; Ostrow, 1983; Young, 1982).

History and development, 1860 to 1960

Context before 1860. The Crimean War of 1853 to 1856, fought by Great Britain, France and Turkey (then the Ottoman Empire) against Russia, is remembered, one account says, mainly for a poem and for Nightingale (Shafritz & Borick, 2011). Her polar area graph, based on the mortality rates of British soldiers during the war, is described as part of an empirically based strategy that led to major reforms in military and civilian hospitals and modernised nursing in the mid- to late-Victorian period (Magnello, 2012).

The mid-nineteenth century. One overview places the start of the evolution of quality improvement and patient safety towards present methods in the mid-19th century (O’Kelly et al., 2019). Nightingale’s investigations, supported by the statistician William Farr, showed that environmental cleanliness helped prevent the spread of disease and supported her case for hospital reform and educated nurses (Kudzma, 2006). Her ideas travelled: the Spanish hygienist Pedro Felipe Monlau cited her eleven times and called for hospital statistics following her proposal (Santainés-Borredá, 2022). Quality questions also arose outside hospitals. In two mid-nineteenth-century North American day nurseries, quality meant saving children’s lives, and concern for safety entrenched a custodial mode of care (Prochner, 1996).

Professions and standards, from 1867. In Canada, organisations for standards, accreditation and continuing medical education evolved after Confederation in 1867 (Baxter, 1996). Codman (1869 to 1940) developed the end-result idea (Kaska & Weinstein, 1998), which helped shape institutions in American medicine (Dervishaj et al., 2015), and a title examines reform and professional dissent in the careers of Richard Cabot and Codman between 1900 and 1920 (Crenner, 2001).

Undated in the corpus. Codman’s efforts, one review states, contributed to the founding of the American College of Surgeons, which catalysed a national quality initiative and the formation of the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Hospitals (Hines et al., 2020). No abstract gives a founding year for either body, so neither is placed in a period here.

Medical education and measurement, 1910 to 1942. In 1910 Abraham Flexner, commissioned by the Carnegie Foundation, surveyed all US and Canadian medical schools; his efforts and those of the American Medical Association closed scores of inadequate schools (Doukas et al., 2010). Around World War I, quantitative parameters helped the field mature (O’Kelly et al., 2019). In 1942 the Association of American Medical Colleges and the American Medical Association created a joint board for medical school surveys that became the Liaison Committee on Medical Education (Kassebaum, 1992).

After 1960 (later, briefly). Donabedian’s seminal text on quality dates from 1966 (Gasparini et al., 2026); the Medicare Peer Review Organization program was established by a 1982 law (Bhatia et al., 2000); the Anesthesia Patient Safety Foundation was created in 1985 (Eichhorn, 2012); and the Health Care Quality Improvement Act of 1986 is the subject of a historical review (Horner, 1990). Figure 2 shows only years stated in titles or abstracts.

Milestones with years stated in the corpus (focus period 1860 to 1960)Before or c. 1860Focus period, 1860 to 1960Later, after 19601853 to 1856Crimean War, thesetting of Nightingale’swar statisticsMid-19th c.QIPS begins toevolve towards itspresent methods1867Confederation inCanada; standardsbodies evolve after1869 to 1940Life of ErnestAmory Codman andthe end result idea1900 to 1920Cabot and Codman:organisationalreform and dissent1910Flexner survey ofUS and Canadianmedical schoolsAround WWIQuantitativeparameters helpQIPS mature1942AAMC-AMA jointboard for schoolsurveys (LCME)1966Donabedian’sseminal text onquality1982TEFRA sets upthe Medicare PROprogramme1985Anesthesia PatientSafety Foundationcreated1986Health CareQuality ImprovementAct (title)Not to scale. “Mid-19th c.” is approximate and sits at the edge of the focus period. No founding years are given for the AmericanCollege of Surgeons or the Joint Commission, so they are not placed. QIPS: quality improvement and patient safety.
Figure 2. Timeline of milestones whose years are stated in the titles or abstracts of the corpus, left to right. Sources: Shafritz & Borick, 2011; McDonald, 2014; O’Kelly et al., 2019; Baxter, 1996; Kaska & Weinstein, 1998; Crenner, 2001; Doukas et al., 2010; O’Kelly et al., 2019; Kassebaum, 1992; Gasparini et al., 2026; Bhatia et al., 2000; Eichhorn, 2012; Horner, 1990. Items after 1960 are shown for context and are labelled as later.

Definitions of quality in the historical literature

No record in the corpus abstracts offers a single agreed definition of quality; its meaning changed with the institution and the problem in view. Table 1 gathers the clearest statements, which, read thematically rather than in table order, move from survival, to outcomes and their comparison, to standards, to performance and change, and finally to quality as an object of power.

Source Year Discipline Definition (paraphrased) Emphasised dimension
Luce et al., 1994 1994 Health policy (United States) Traditional quality control stressed case-by-case analysis and identifying outliers; newer approaches create practice guidelines and profiles of hospitals and physicians Review method
Prochner, 1996 1996 Early childhood care history In two mid-nineteenth-century North American day nurseries, quality was associated with saving children’s lives within charity-based social welfare Survival and safety
Spiegelhalter, 1999 1999 Statistics Surgical audit examines and compares surgical outcomes, either through uniform statistics (Nightingale’s “epidemiological” approach) or through full and honest appraisal of errors (Codman’s “clinical” approach) Comparison of outcomes; honesty about error
Colton, 2000 2000 Programme evaluation Quality improvement is the primary approach for health care organisations to measure performance and implement change Performance and change
McDonald, 2010 2010 Nursing For Nightingale, statistics served to indicate serious problems, to assist policy making and to monitor the effects of new policies Evaluation and monitoring
Dervishaj et al., 2015 2015 Surgery The end-result system records surgical complications and analyses them to determine a surgeon’s ability and a hospital’s efficiency Accountability of surgeon and hospital
Russell & Ko, 2023 2023 Colorectal surgery Accreditation first aimed to set a minimum standard of care and now more prominently sets standards for high-quality, optimal care Standards
Gasparini et al., 2026 2026 Health assessment (Brazil) Donabedian’s 1966 concept of quality reflects contradictions and power struggles between medical autonomy and the demand for quality control Power and professional autonomy
Table 1. Definitions of quality and related ideas in the corpus, ordered by publication year. Definitions are paraphrased from the abstracts.

Three points stand out. Outcome and comparison come early: Nightingale’s uniform statistics and Codman’s honest appraisal of errors are both ways of comparing surgical outcomes (Spiegelhalter, 1999). Standards come with institutions, as accreditation moved from minimum to high-quality standards (Russell & Ko, 2023). And quality is contested: a historical-critical reading of Donabedian’s 1966 text, the most recognised canon of health assessment in Brazil, sees it as a product of disputes between medical autonomy and quality control (Gasparini et al., 2026). Definitions of quality also decide who judges whom.

Figure 3 arranges these ideas into three early streams; the arrangement is a teaching device, but each element comes from the cited abstracts.

Three early streams of quality work and where the corpus says they ledCounting and comparingUniform surgical statisticsMortality and evaluativestatisticsPolar area graphsNightingale and FarrLater (after 1960)Dashboards, infectionprevention and harmsurveillanceFollowing end resultsRecording surgicalcomplicationsEnd-result systemSurgical auditCodman, MoynihanLater (after 1960)Outcome databasesand reporting as aquality toolSetting and checking standards1910 survey of medicalschools (Flexner)Minimum standard of carein early accreditationFlexner, AMA, AAMC-AMA boardLater (after 1960)Accreditation ofhigh-quality care;competency standardsLater: from quality assurance to quality improvementand patient safety (Medicare PRO shift; APSF, 1985)Tensions running through all three streamsprofessional autonomy versus external control; early enthusiasm versus difficulty in following the exampleConceptual scheme for teaching. Elements follow the cited sources; the arrangement is the author’s synthesis.
Figure 3. Conceptual scheme of three early streams of quality work. Counting and comparing follows Spiegelhalter (1999), McDonald (2010), Magnello (2012) and Zrelak (2026); following end results follows Dervishaj et al. (2015), Chambler and Emery (1997), Hines et al. (2020) and Madison (2012); setting and checking standards follows Doukas et al. (2010), Kassebaum (1992), Russell and Ko (2023) and Joyner (2004); the later shift follows Bhatia et al. (2000) and Eichhorn (2012); the tensions follow Gasparini et al. (2026) and Spiegelhalter (1999).

Distinguishing quality of care from neighbouring concepts

Students often use quality of care, patient safety, quality assurance and quality improvement interchangeably. Table 2 separates nine related concepts and gives the earliest date the corpus itself states for each; where none is stated, the table says so.

Concept How the corpus describes it Earliest date stated in the corpus Sources
Quality of care Survival of foundlings and of children in day nurseries; later shaped by disputes over medical autonomy From 1809 (foundling cohorts studied for mortality and quality of care) Gasparini et al., 2026; Kertzer et al., 1999; Prochner, 1996
Patient safety Field traced to Hammurabi, with present methods from the mid-19th century; modern public term attributed to the Anesthesia Patient Safety Foundation’s founders Circa 1700 BC (origin claimed); mid-19th century (present methods); 1985 (modern term, later) Eichhorn, 2012; O’Kelly et al., 2019
End-result idea Recording and analysing complications to judge surgeons and hospitals Codman’s lifetime, 1869 to 1940 Dervishaj et al., 2015; Kaska & Weinstein, 1998
Hospital standardization Minimum standards for hospital accreditation, listed as an undated advance Not stated Hines et al., 2020
Accreditation External evaluation against standards, from minimum to high-quality care From 1867 (Canadian standards and accreditation bodies); 1942 (joint survey board, later the LCME) Baxter, 1996; Kassebaum, 1992; Russell & Ko, 2023
Medical audit Comparing outcomes statistically or through honest appraisal of errors Not stated Spiegelhalter, 1999
Mortality statistics Foundling mortality cohorts; polar area graphs of soldiers’ mortality; maternal mortality in childbirth From 1809 (foundling cohorts); 1853 to 1856 (Crimean War) Kertzer et al., 1999; Magnello, 2012; McDonald, 2010; Shafritz & Borick, 2011
Quality assurance A duty to assure the quality of medical education; later, review of sampled records against clinical criteria 1942 (medical education); 1982 (later; Medicare PRO law) Bhatia et al., 2000; Kassebaum, 1992; Weinmann, 1998
Quality improvement Measuring performance and implementing change; quality circles from manufacturing Circa 1700 BC (origin claimed); mid-19th century (present methods); around World War I (quantitative parameters) Colton, 2000; O’Kelly et al., 2019; Rohrbasser et al., 2018
Table 2. Quality of care and eight neighbouring concepts as described in the corpus. Dates are the earliest stated in a title or abstract; claimed origins are labelled as such.

Two contrasts matter. Quality assurance and quality improvement are not old and new names for one thing: the Medicare programme moved from retrospective review of individual events to proactive improvement (Bhatia et al., 2000) after criticisms of the reliability and validity of its review findings (Weinmann, 1998). Standardisation and accreditation also differ: in this guide’s usage, standardisation defines what a hospital must have, while accreditation is continuing external evaluation, which one account expects to involve the public, purchasers and government in setting standards (Schyve, 2000). Figure 4 compares the nine concepts; its ratings are the author’s synthesis.

Quality of care and its neighbours: which features are central?OutcomefocusComparativestatisticsWrittenstandardsExternalbodyPeer orself-reviewContinuouscycleHarmpreventionQuality of carePatient safetyEnd-result ideaHospital standardizationAccreditationMedical auditMortality statisticsQuality assuranceQuality improvementcentralpartly or sometimesnot centralAuthor’s synthesis for teaching, not an empirical rating.
Figure 4. Matrix comparing quality of care (shaded row) with eight neighbouring concepts on seven features. The ratings are the author’s synthesis, not a finding of the corpus; see Table 2 for cited evidence on each concept.

Pioneers and their ideas

Nightingale matches 21 of the 86 records, Codman 9 and Flexner 6 (overlapping keyword counts). Each is described here only as the titles and abstracts describe them (Table 3).

Florence Nightingale (1820 to 1910). Widely recognised as the founder of modern nursing, Nightingale is now reframed as an early applied statistician whose data collection, analysis and graphics influenced health policy (Zrelak, 2026). McDonald (2010) describes more than 40 years of applied statistical work: she adapted Quetelet’s methods, monitored public health care systems, carried out a pioneering study of maternal mortality in childbirth and pioneered evaluative statistics, using data to indicate problems, assist policy and monitor the effects of new policies. She used medical statistics to reveal the nature of infection in hospitals and on the battlefield, which Aravind and Chung (2010) call evidence-based reform more than a century before Cochrane and Sackett. Her suggestion for uniform surgical statistics began an “epidemiological” approach to surgical outcomes, and she clearly predicted the problems of collecting and interpreting such data (Spiegelhalter, 1999). A management history paper calls her a “nineteenth century apostle of quality” (Meyer & Bishop, 2007), and a nursing paper draws on Notes on Nursing to present hygiene, cleanliness, environment and systematic care as foundations for reducing harm (Alcantara et al., 2026). Titles add her statistical table for hospitals (Brasseur, 2016) and her research-based approach to hospital safety (McDonald, 2015).

Ernest Amory Codman (1869 to 1940). Codman is described as unappreciated in his career and largely uncelebrated today, yet as a major contributor to outcomes research whose persistence helped move medicine from a 19th century artisan style to a scientific basis (Kaska & Weinstein, 1998). He recorded surgical complications and analysed them to judge a surgeon’s ability and a hospital’s efficiency; colleagues did not welcome the idea, but his influence helped shape the Joint Commission (Dervishaj et al., 2015). Spiegelhalter (1999) calls his approach “clinical”: a search for full and honest appraisals of surgical errors. Donabedian (1989) wrote on Codman’s contribution to quality assessment (title only), and other titles link Codman to audit through Lord Moynihan (Chambler & Emery, 1997) and to complication assessment in a case of flap ischaemia (Greene et al., 2007).

Abraham Flexner. Flexner’s 1910 survey found proprietary schools with inadequate scholarship and substandard faculty and teaching venues; he saw the humanities as essential but did not build them explicitly into the report (Doukas et al., 2010). His analysis transformed student selection, instruction and faculty roles and led to the near universal adoption of the academic medical centre (Prislin et al., 2010). One review groups him with Codman as innovators whose reviews of systems and outcomes ignited interest in quality improvement (Hines et al., 2020).

Others. William Farr supported Nightingale’s investigations (Kudzma, 2006); Edwin Chadwick appears beside her in a title on sanitary reform (Widerquist, 1997); a title describes the contributions of the neurosurgeon Sir William Macewen to an early quality assurance survey in anaesthesia (Frost, 1991). In the later period, a title calls Donabedian the “father of quality assurance” (Best & Neuhauser, 2004), and Deming and Juran appear as early quality gurus whose promise of continual improvement has not been fully realised (Lahidji & Tucker, 2016).

Person Period Idea Lasting contribution Citation
Florence Nightingale 1820 to 1910; Crimean War 1853 to 1856 Uniform surgical statistics; evaluative and mortality statistics; polar area graphs Data-driven hospital and nursing reform Magnello, 2012; McDonald, 2010; Shafritz & Borick, 2011; Spiegelhalter, 1999; Zrelak, 2026
William Farr Not stated Statistics supporting Nightingale’s investigations Statistical backing for reform Kudzma, 2006
Pedro Felipe Monlau Nineteenth century Hospital statistics following Nightingale Her ideas carried to Spain Santainés-Borredá, 2022
Ernest Amory Codman 1869 to 1940 End-result idea Outcomes research; influence on the Joint Commission Dervishaj et al., 2015; Kaska & Weinstein, 1998
Richard Cabot 1900 to 1920 (title only) Organisational reform and dissent Not stated Crenner, 2001
Lord Moynihan Not stated (title only) Bringing Codman into audit Surgical audit Chambler & Emery, 1997
Abraham Flexner 1910 report Survey and standardisation of medical education School closures; academic medical centre model Doukas et al., 2010; Prislin et al., 2010
Avedis Donabedian (later) 1966 text Concept of quality in health assessment Canon of health assessment in Brazil Gasparini et al., 2026
Table 3. Pioneers named in the corpus, with periods only as stated in titles or abstracts.

Institutions and programmes

The American College of Surgeons and hospital standardization. Codman’s efforts contributed to the founding of the college, which catalysed a quality improvement initiative across the United States and the formation of the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Hospitals; the same review lists the defining of minimum standards for hospital accreditation among later, undated advances, without crediting it to the college (Hines et al., 2020). Accreditation, in its earliest iterations, aimed at a minimum standard of care and shaped the structure and organisation of American medicine (Russell & Ko, 2023). The corpus does not describe the hospital standardization programme in detail, and no abstract dates it.

The Joint Commission. A 1987 history of the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Hospitals survives only as a title (Roberts et al., 1987). Schyve (2000) calls the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations the oldest health care accrediting body in the world, accrediting almost 20 000 organisations in the USA; it remained professionally sponsored, but its recent growth had been driven by government, purchasers and the public rather than by professionals.

Accreditation of medical education. After Flexner’s 1910 survey, scores of inadequate schools closed (Doukas et al., 2010). The 1942 meeting that created a joint survey board, later the Liaison Committee on Medical Education, sought among other things economies in the profession’s duty to assure the quality of medical education (Kassebaum, 1992). In Canada, standards and accreditation bodies evolved after 1867 (Baxter, 1996), and the later Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education standards use tools representing six core competencies (Joyner, 2004).

Audit and peer review. A 1997 title says that Lord Moynihan “cuts Codman into audit” (Chambler & Emery, 1997). Traditional quality control in the United States stressed case-by-case analysis and identifying outliers (Luce et al., 1994). Peer review groups or quality circles of 6 to 12 professionals now meet regularly across Europe; they originated in manufacturing industry (Rohrbasser et al., 2018).

Later programmes (after 1960). The Medicare Peer Review Organization program, established by the Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act of 1982 (Bhatia et al., 2000), is dated by another account to the mid 1980s (Weinmann, 1998). A military quality assurance programme was built incrementally on organisational structures, data sources and standard measures (Granger et al., 2010), and a title traces reporting as a quality tool from the Health Care Quality Improvement Act to the Affordable Care Act (Madison, 2012). In Brazil, regulation culminated in a National Patient Safety Program in 2013 (Santana et al., 2020).

Methods that emerged and their later descendants

1. Statistics and mortality comparisons. Nightingale’s polar area graph drew on nineteenth-century statistical graphics; she added new elements to it and helped make it iconic (Magnello, 2012). McDonald (2014) adapts her charts to portray the relative causes of war hospital deaths more accurately and reports French comparisons of British and French Army deaths. The later descendant is measurement for improvement: Zrelak (2026), in a conceptual analysis, considers how her mortality data could be reinterpreted with interrupted time-series methods and comparative dashboards, noting the limitations of nineteenth-century data systems. In the United States, quality measurement is called fundamental to improvement, yet progress has been somewhat limited by misaligned measures, fragmentation and a lack of national electronic systems (Burstin et al., 2016).

2. End-result reporting. Codman’s system recorded and analysed surgical complications (Dervishaj et al., 2015). Its descendants are outcome databases and registries: large outcome databases in spinal surgery (Hines et al., 2020) and multi-institutional quality improvement registries, many formed by medical societies, which have supported treatment guidelines, research and demonstrations of value; interventional radiology has committed to building such a registry (Caplin et al., 2023). US payers increasingly mandate measurement and reporting for pay-for-performance (Burstin et al., 2016).

3. Standards. Early accreditation aimed at a minimum standard of care (Russell & Ko, 2023), and one title says the Flexner report standardised American medical education (Beck, 2004). Schyve (2000) expected later external evaluation to borrow from industry, incorporating aspects of the Baldrige, European Foundation for Quality Management and ISO 9000 approaches. A small cross-sector survey, not specific to health care, of about 100 quality professionals found nearly all regarded compliance with an external standard such as ISO as mandatory, but they disagreed about whether its continuous improvement requirement actually functions (Lahidji & Tucker, 2016).

4. Audit. Spiegelhalter (1999) contrasts Nightingale’s epidemiological and Codman’s clinical approaches to surgical audit and recommends a synthesis, warning of inevitable extra-statistical difficulties. A later form of retrospective review, related to audit in this guide’s reading, was Medicare peer review: reviewers judged a random sample of records against locally developed criteria until criticisms of reliability and validity led to a refocus on quality improvement (Weinmann, 1998).

5. Control charts and industrial methods. The search included Shewhart’s name, but no included abstract describes Shewhart or control charts. The nearest record is a title on “the seven basic tools of quality” in paediatric surgery that lists control charts and statistical process control among its author keywords (Tagge et al., 2026), followed by a title on the origin of quality improvement in scientific management (Hays, 1994). This is a gap in the corpus, not evidence that such methods were absent.

The link to later quality improvement. The corpus describes a change of emphasis rather than a clean break. Quality improvement and evaluation developed separately but began to merge (Colton, 2000); review shifted from retrospective, event-based review to proactive improvement (Bhatia et al., 2000); and guidelines and provider profiles were added to case-by-case review (Luce et al., 1994). The later patient safety movement added systems-level solutions and checklists, and one review recommends adopting teamwork training proven in aviation (Lark et al., 2018).

Historiography: myths, contested credit and re-readings

In this guide’s reading, much of this history is written by clinicians and managers (only 3 records are in a history category), which invites heroic stories. The corpus also contains a counter-current that corrects myths and asks whose story is being told.

Correcting myths. Magnello (2012) argues that the popular image of Nightingale as the “Lady with the Lamp” undermines her prodigious statistical work; Meyer and Bishop (2007) found her contribution to quality management virtually undiscussed; and a Spanish study calls for revisiting biographies to make women scientists visible (Santainés-Borredá, 2022). Historical work also rebuts blame. McDonald (2014) rejects the claim in the secondary literature that Nightingale was responsible for the high death rates in the war hospitals, using comparative death rate data, and Kertzer et al. (1999) take issue with the view that wetnurses and foster mothers were largely to blame for the excess mortality of foundlings in nineteenth-century Bologna, Italy.

Contested credit. Aravind and Chung (2010) note that most trace evidence-based medicine to Cochrane and Sackett, but they trace it to Nightingale, while Kaska and Weinstein (1998) trace it to Codman. For patient safety, Eichhorn (2012) credits the founders of the Anesthesia Patient Safety Foundation with coining the modern public term and creating the very first patient safety organisation, while O’Kelly et al. (2019) go back to Hammurabi, around 1700 BC. These claims cannot all describe a single origin; in this guide’s reading, each tends to reflect the author’s field.

Codman and Flexner re-read. Codman is the unappreciated visionary (Kaska & Weinstein, 1998), but a title in a history of medicine journal frames the careers of Cabot and Codman around organisational reform and professional dissent (Crenner, 2001), which places conflict, not only vision, in the story. Flexner is praised for observations still pertinent today (Crass & Romanelli, 2018), yet one title argues that his report standardised medical students through region-, gender- and race-based hierarchies (Bailey, 2017), and another presents the generalist disciplines a century later as a case of unintended consequences (Prislin et al., 2010). Donabedian’s 1966 concept of quality has been read through historical epistemology and materialist discourse analysis as a product of disputes over medical autonomy (Gasparini et al., 2026).

New lenses. The HIQI matrix maps current service quality against historical data on the same services (Creese et al., 2026), and a critical review treats quality as a diffusing innovation (Osman et al., 2026). A title asks whether quality has evolved convergently or divergently across countries and cultures (Buchan, 1998), a question this largely American corpus cannot answer.

Themes and bibliometric profile

Growth over time. The records span 1982 to 2026 (Figure 5): 28 from 1982 to 1999, 16 from 2000 to 2009, 27 from 2010 to 2019 and 15 from 2020 to 2026. No year has more than 7 records; 2010 and 2026 have 7 each, and 2026 is a partial year. In 2010 two records in Academic Medicine revisit the Flexner report (Doukas et al., 2010; Prislin et al., 2010).

Included records per publication year, 1982 to 2026 (n = 86)1982 to 1999: 282000 to 2009: 162010 to 2019: 272020 to 2026: 150246812111985113319901121995333232000111322005122720102412201541513202021220257Alternating shaded bands mark the four periods; counts per period are shown at the top.Orange bar: 2026, which covers part of the year only (search date 18 November 2026). Years without a bar have no records.
Figure 5. Included records per publication year (Web of Science Core Collection, searched 18 November 2026), with counts for four periods. The 2026 count covers part of the year only.

Themes. Keyword matches in titles, abstracts and author keywords (Figure 6) give statistics or outcomes data 27 records, Nightingale 21, the Joint Commission or accreditation 13, nursing 11, Codman 9, Flexner 6, the end result idea 3, Donabedian 3, medical or clinical audit 3, hospital standardization or the American College of Surgeons 2, Shewhart or Deming 2 and Semmelweis 0. A record can match several groups, so the counts overlap and sum to 100. The matches use exact keyword patterns, so a hyphenated spelling such as “end-result” is not counted.

Records matching each theme keyword group (a record can match several)051015202530Statistics or outcomes data27Nightingale21Joint Commission or accreditation13Nursing11Codman9Flexner6End result idea3Donabedian3Medical or clinical audit3Hospital standardization or ACS2Shewhart or Deming2Semmelweis0Keyword matches in title, abstract and author keywords of the 86 included records. Counts overlap.
Figure 6. Number of included records whose title, abstract or author keywords match each theme keyword group. A record can match several groups, so the counts overlap; they add up to 100. Exact keyword patterns are used, so hyphenated spellings such as “end-result” are not counted.

Countries, journals and fields. By affiliation address, 49 records include authors in the USA, 7 in Canada, 6 in the UK, 3 in Brazil, 2 in Australia and 1 each in Switzerland, Spain, Peru, Pakistan and New Zealand; a record can count for several countries; 20 records have no affiliation address, 13 of which list only a reprint address, so 7 have no address of any kind. The records appeared in 75 journals and books: Academic Medicine published 4; JAMA, American Journal of Law & Medicine, Evaluation & the Health Professions, Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A: Statistics in Society, International Journal for Quality in Health Care, Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Journal of Legal Medicine and Journal of Pediatric Urology published 2 each; the other 66 published one each. Leading Web of Science categories (a record can have several) are Health Care Sciences & Services (14), Surgery (12), Health Policy & Services (10), Medicine, General & Internal (8), Nursing (7), Anesthesiology, Education, Scientific Disciplines and Management (5 each), and Public, Environmental & Occupational Health, Law and Pediatrics (4 each). Only 3 records are in History & Philosophy of Science.

The history of quality in Türkiye

No included record has an author affiliated in Türkiye, and only one mentions Turkey, Türkiye or Turkish in its title, abstract or keywords. That record, a public administration case on Nightingale, names Turkey (then the Ottoman Empire) once, as one of the powers that fought with Great Britain and France against Russia in the Crimean War of 1853 to 1856 (Shafritz & Borick, 2011). It reports no Turkish setting, institution or finding on quality of care, and the abstracts on Nightingale’s war statistics do not name where the war hospitals were (McDonald, 2014).

Missing is almost everything: the Ottoman and early Republican history of hospital organisation, medical statistics, education standards and inspection, and the reception of Nightingale’s or Codman’s ideas in Turkish medicine. Their absence shows only that Web of Science titles do not capture them. Turkish-language historical journals, archives and books are the obvious next sources.

Debates and contradictions in the literature

Heroic pioneers or institutional history? Many accounts celebrate individuals: Codman’s courage and persistence (Kaska & Weinstein, 1998), Nightingale as an “apostle of quality” (Meyer & Bishop, 2007) and an early architect of data-driven improvement (Zrelak, 2026), Donabedian as the “father of quality assurance” (Best & Neuhauser, 2004). Others put institutions and circumstances first. The joint board that became the Liaison Committee on Medical Education came from a wartime meeting with practical aims, such as protecting students from the draft (Kassebaum, 1992); and accreditation’s recent growth was driven by external users rather than professionals (Schyve, 2000). The two stories meet where Codman’s efforts are linked to the American College of Surgeons and the Joint Commission (Hines et al., 2020). In this guide’s view they are best read together: ideas needed institutions to last, and institutions needed ideas to standardise.

Codman: visionary or contested figure? Both readings have support. He made profound contributions but was unappreciated (Kaska & Weinstein, 1998), his colleagues did not welcome his end-result idea (Dervishaj et al., 2015), and his career is framed by professional dissent (Crenner, 2001). Spiegelhalter (1999) adds that, despite initial enthusiasm, others had great difficulty following Codman’s example, just as those who implemented Nightingale’s surgical statistics appeared not to share her insight. Being right early was not enough.

Did early standards improve outcomes? The corpus does not show this for 1860 to 1960. Nightingale’s graphs are said to have led to major reforms (Magnello, 2012), and Flexner’s work closed scores of schools and radically changed curricula (Doukas et al., 2010), but these are changes in structure and process, not measured patient outcomes. Some evidence cuts the other way: in nineteenth-century day nurseries, concern for safety entrenched a custodial mode of care (Prochner, 1996), and a century after Flexner, following public research funding and late-20th-century financing changes, the system is described as scientifically advanced yet failing on affordability, equitable access and quality (Prislin et al., 2010). Later evidence is mixed. Medicare review was refocused after criticisms of its reliability and validity (Weinmann, 1998); quality circles can change behaviour, but effect sizes vary with topic and context (Rohrbasser et al., 2018); and US quality measurement has made somewhat limited progress (Burstin et al., 2016). On the positive side, a 25th-anniversary retrospective describes the Anesthesia Patient Safety Foundation as nationally recognised for a dramatic positive impact on anaesthesia safety (Eichhorn, 2012).

Continuity or rupture? For continuity, Nightingale’s principles are said to align closely with current patient safety frameworks and the World Health Organization’s Global Action Plan (Alcantara et al., 2026), and many of Flexner’s observations remain pertinent (Crass & Romanelli, 2018). For rupture, the marked acceleration of patient safety policy in the five years before 2002 is attributed to a culture of transparency, computer networks, an aggressive media, cost containment and validated data on preventable injuries (Small & Barach, 2002), and quality improvement and patient safety gained importance particularly after the report To Err is Human (Koyle et al., 2018). The questions persisted while the data, institutions and pressures changed. Some problems persist too; in a maternity care example, racial and unconscious bias and lack of voice recurred across the years and were judged unreliable targets for quality improvement approaches alone (Creese et al., 2026).

Research gaps and agenda

  1. Dating the institutions. No abstract gives founding years for the American College of Surgeons or the Joint Commission or describes hospital standardization in detail.
  2. Outcome evidence for early reforms. Reanalyses of historical data, such as the adapted Crimean charts (McDonald, 2014), or the reinterpretation of Nightingale’s data with time-series methods that a conceptual analysis proposes, mindful of nineteenth-century data limits (Zrelak, 2026), could test whether reforms changed outcomes.
  3. Geographic breadth. Most records have authors in the USA; work on Spain (Santainés-Borredá, 2022) and Brazil (Santana et al., 2020) shows what comparison adds, and Türkiye is absent.
  4. Industrial methods. No abstract describes Shewhart or control charts (one record lists control charts only as an author keyword), and Semmelweis matches no record.
  5. Hidden actors. Nurses, women scientists and patients sit at the margins; calls to make women scientists visible (Santainés-Borredá, 2022) and oral histories with Black women who used maternity services (Creese et al., 2026) show ways to widen the story.
  6. The older literature. 35 records, many from the 1980s and 1990s, have no abstract and need full-text review.
  7. From history to practice. Insights from historical reviews need validation across diverse settings (Osman et al., 2026), alongside theory-driven research (Rohrbasser et al., 2018) and measures that matter (Burstin et al., 2016).

Implications for practice today

History gives quality managers tested warnings rather than tools. Good data are necessary but not sufficient: Nightingale foresaw the problems of collecting and interpreting surgical statistics, and those who implemented her scheme did not share her insight (Spiegelhalter, 1999). Honest review of individual results provokes resistance, as Codman found (Dervishaj et al., 2015), so culture matters as much as forms, and one review recommends teamwork training of the kind used in aviation (Lark et al., 2018). Minimum standards are only a floor (Russell & Ko, 2023), and accreditation stays credible only when those who rely on it are involved (Schyve, 2000). Standardisation can have side effects (Prislin et al., 2010). And organisations forget, which is why historically informed improvement looks back at the same service to find what lasted and what never changed (Creese et al., 2026). Table 4 summarises these links.

Historical idea Modern counterpart Lesson
Uniform surgical statistics (Spiegelhalter, 1999) Clinical registries (Caplin et al., 2023) Agree definitions and anticipate interpretation problems before comparing providers
Polar area graphs (Magnello, 2012) Dashboards and harm surveillance (Zrelak, 2026) Graphics persuade; check that they portray causes accurately (McDonald, 2014)
End-result system (Dervishaj et al., 2015) Outcome databases (Hines et al., 2020) Expect resistance; build a culture of honest appraisal
Minimum standard of care in early accreditation (Russell & Ko, 2023) Accreditation for high-quality care (Russell & Ko, 2023) Standards are a floor; credibility needs stakeholder involvement (Schyve, 2000)
Standardised medical education (Beck, 2004; Doukas et al., 2010) Standards with competency tools (Joyner, 2004) Watch for unintended consequences and hierarchies (Bailey, 2017; Prislin et al., 2010)
Case-by-case review (Luce et al., 1994) Quality improvement (Bhatia et al., 2000) Review must be reliable and valid to keep support (Weinmann, 1998)
Historical service records (Creese et al., 2026) HIQI matrix (Creese et al., 2026) Use the past to find problems that improvement has not solved
Table 4. Historical ideas, modern counterparts and lessons for quality managers. Pairings are the author’s synthesis.

Summary

  • Between 1860 and 1960 three streams of quality work took shape: counting and comparing (Nightingale), following end results (Codman) and setting and checking standards (Flexner, the American College of Surgeons, the Joint Commission, medical education boards).
  • Recent work reframes Nightingale as an applied statistician, not only the “Lady with the Lamp”.
  • Codman’s end-result idea was not welcomed by his colleagues, yet he is now cited as a forerunner of outcomes research.
  • Flexner’s 1910 survey led to school closures and standardisation, with consequences later authors call unintended.
  • Accreditation moved from minimum standards to high-quality care; whether compliance with standards improved outcomes is not shown in this corpus.
  • The corpus offers no outcome evidence for early standards, no founding dates for the college or the Joint Commission, no abstract describing control charts and nothing on Türkiye beyond one Crimean War mention.

Discussion questions

  1. What does Nightingale’s “epidemiological” approach to audit see that Codman’s “clinical” approach misses, and vice versa?
  2. Why might Codman’s colleagues have resisted the end-result idea, and do those reasons still apply to public reporting?
  3. Several authors claim Nightingale or Codman as the origin of evidence-based medicine. What is gained and lost by choosing a founder?
  4. How should the benefits of the Flexner report be weighed against the hierarchies it is linked to?
  5. Applied: what data would show that accreditation improved outcomes in your hospital?
  6. Applied: which historical records would you seek for an improvement project in a Turkish hospital?

Further reading

  • Spiegelhalter (1999): a statistician’s comparison of Nightingale’s and Codman’s approaches to surgical audit, with a case for combining them.
  • Kaska and Weinstein (1998): an accessible account of Codman’s life and the end-result idea as a forerunner of evidence-based medicine.
  • McDonald (2010): Nightingale’s applied statistics, from Quetelet’s methods to her study of maternal mortality.
  • McDonald (2014): a re-analysis of the Crimean War polar area charts and a rebuttal of the claim that Nightingale was responsible for the high war hospital death rates.
  • Gasparini et al. (2026): a critical reading of Donabedian’s notion of quality as shaped by disputes over medical autonomy.
  • Creese et al. (2026): a practical tool for using historical evidence in present-day quality improvement.

Glossary

Term Turkish Short definition
Quality of care Bakım kalitesi The degree to which care meets the aims set for it; its meaning has changed over time
Patient safety Hasta güvenliği Preventing harm to patients from care; one account dates the modern public term to 1985
End-result idea Son sonuç fikri Codman’s practice of recording and analysing the results of treatment to judge surgeons and hospitals
Hospital standardization Hastane standardizasyonu Defining minimum standards that hospitals must meet
Accreditation Akreditasyon External evaluation of an organisation or programme against published standards
Medical audit Tıbbi denetim Examining and comparing the outcomes of care, statistically or through review of individual cases
Quality assurance Kalite güvencesi Review of care against criteria to assure that it meets them, often retrospective
Quality improvement Kalite iyileştirme Measuring performance and implementing change to make care better
Polar area graph Kutupsal alan grafiği A circular chart in which the area of each segment shows a quantity, used by Nightingale for mortality data
Quality circle Kalite çemberi A small group of professionals that meets regularly to reflect on and improve practice

Frequently asked questions

Who started quality improvement in health care? No single person. Authors trace evidence-based reform to Nightingale (Aravind & Chung, 2010) and evidence-based medicine to Codman (Kaska & Weinstein, 1998); a title links quality improvement to scientific management (Hays, 1994), and one account traces quality improvement and patient safety back to Hammurabi (O’Kelly et al., 2019).

What was Codman’s end-result idea? Recording and analysing surgical complications to judge a surgeon’s ability and a hospital’s efficiency (Dervishaj et al., 2015).

Why does Nightingale matter for quality? She used statistics to reveal problems, support policy and monitor its effects (McDonald, 2010) and proposed uniform surgical statistics (Spiegelhalter, 1999).

When was the Joint Commission founded? The abstracts do not say; they state that the American College of Surgeons catalysed its formation (Hines et al., 2020).

Did early standards improve outcomes? The corpus does not show this; it documents structural reforms such as school closures (Doukas et al., 2010), and later evidence on review programmes and quality circles is mixed (Rohrbasser et al., 2018; Weinmann, 1998).

Related on this site: Quality improvement methods (TQM, CQI, PDSA): an introduction (101) · Harvard Medical Practice Study: an introduction (101) · High reliability organizations in health care: an introduction (101)

References

  • Alcantara, E. L., da Silva, C. P. G., de Almeida Filho, A. J., Cavalcanti, H. C. N., Duarte, S. da C. M., & Santos, T. C. F. (2026). Florence Nightingale’s contemporary legacy for patient safety: Implications for nursing and public health. Nursing Inquiry, 33(4), Article e70149. https://doi.org/10.1111/nin.70149
  • Aravind, M., & Chung, K. C. (2010). Evidence-based medicine and hospital reform: Tracing origins back to Florence Nightingale. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 125(1), 403-409. https://doi.org/10.1097/PRS.0b013e3181c2bb89
  • Bailey, M. (2017). The Flexner report: Standardizing medical students through region-, gender-, and race-based hierarchies. American Journal of Law & Medicine, 43(2-3), 209-223. https://doi.org/10.1177/0098858817723660
  • Baxter, J. D. (1996). The history of otolaryngology in Canada: The provincial and regional organizations concerned with standards, accreditation, and continuing medical education. Journal of Otolaryngology, 25(5), 349-356.
  • Beck, A. H. (2004). The Flexner report and the standardization of American medical education. JAMA, 291(17), 2139-2140. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.291.17.2139
  • Best, M., & Neuhauser, D. (2004). Avedis Donabedian: Father of quality assurance and poet. Quality & Safety in Health Care, 13(6), 472-473. https://doi.org/10.1136/qshc.2004.012591
  • Bhatia, A. J., Blackstock, S., Nelson, R., & Ng, T. S. (2000). Evolution of quality review programs for Medicare: Quality assurance to quality improvement. Health Care Financing Review, 22(1), 69-74.
  • Brasseur, L. E. (2016). Florence Nightingale’s statistical table for hospitals: A work of utility and art. In M. A. Kimball & C. Kostelnick (Eds.), Visible numbers: Essays on the history of statistical graphics (pp. 43-59). Routledge.
  • Buchan, H. (1998). Different countries, different cultures: Convergent or divergent evolution for healthcare quality? Quality in Health Care, 7(Suppl.), S62-S67.
  • Burstin, H., Leatherman, S., & Goldmann, D. (2016). The evolution of healthcare quality measurement in the United States. Journal of Internal Medicine, 279(2), 154-159. https://doi.org/10.1111/joim.12471
  • Caplin, D. M., Young, S., Kassin, M., Dowell, J. D., Makary, M. S., Metwalli, Z. A., Charalel, R. A., Halin, N. J., Kleedehn, M., Lewis, P. B., Ward, T. J., & Shah, R. P. (2023). A history and modern framework for quality improvement in interventional radiology. Journal of Vascular and Interventional Radiology, 34(11), 2012-2019. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvir.2023.07.019
  • Chambler, A. F. W., & Emery, R. J. H. (1997). Lord Moynihan cuts Codman into audit. Annals of the Royal College of Surgeons of England, 79(4 Suppl.), 174-176.
  • Colton, D. (2000). Quality improvement in health care: Conceptual and historical foundation. Evaluation & the Health Professions, 23(1), 7-42. https://doi.org/10.1177/01632780022034462
  • Crass, R. L., & Romanelli, F. (2018). Curricular reform in pharmacy education through the lens of the Flexner report of 1910. American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education, 82(7), 726-731.
  • Creese, J., Kumaravel, B., Moss, K., Chapman, M., Darko, N., Cox, F., & Abeyratne, R. (2026). Historically informed quality improvement: Applying historical insights from Black women’s maternity care to contemporary health service redesign. International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 38(3), Article mzag113. https://doi.org/10.1093/intqhc/mzag113
  • Crenner, C. (2001). Organizational reform and professional dissent in the careers of Richard Cabot and Ernest Amory Codman, 1900-1920. Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences, 56(3), 211-237. https://doi.org/10.1093/jhmas/56.3.211
  • Dervishaj, O., Wright, K. E., Saber, A. A., & Pappas, P. J. (2015). Ernest Amory Codman and the end-result system. American Surgeon, 81(1), 12-15.
  • Donabedian, A. (1989). The end results of health care: Ernest Codman’s contribution to quality assessment and beyond. Milbank Quarterly, 67(2), 233-256. https://doi.org/10.2307/3350139
  • Dorsey, D. B. (1989). Evolving concepts of quality in laboratory practice: A historical overview of quality assurance in clinical laboratories. Archives of Pathology & Laboratory Medicine, 113(12), 1329-1334.
  • Doukas, D. J., McCullough, L. B., & Wear, S. (2010). Reforming medical education in ethics and humanities by finding common ground with Abraham Flexner. Academic Medicine, 85(2), 318-323. https://doi.org/10.1097/ACM.0b013e3181c85932
  • Eichhorn, J. H. (2012). The Anesthesia Patient Safety Foundation at 25: A pioneering success in safety, 25th anniversary provokes reflection, anticipation. Anesthesia and Analgesia, 114(4), 791-800. https://doi.org/10.1213/ANE.0b013e3182427536
  • Fine, D. J., & Meyer, E. R. (1983). Quality assurance in historical perspective. Hospital & Health Services Administration, 28(6), 94-121.
  • Frost, E. A. M. (1991). The contributions of Sir William Macewen, a pioneer neurosurgeon, to an early quality assurance survey in anesthesia. Journal of Neurosurgical Anesthesiology, 3(1), 28-33.
  • Gasparini, M. F. V., Oda, W. Y., Barbosa Filho, F. R., & Furtado, J. P. (2026). Between autonomy and control of medical care: A historical-critical understanding of the notion of quality in health assessment. Ciência & Saúde Coletiva, 31(10), Article e03042025. https://doi.org/10.1590/1413-812320263110.03042025EN
  • Granger, E., Boyer, J., Weiss, R., Linton, A., & Williams, T. V. (2010). Historical evolution of medical quality assurance in the Department of Defense. Military Medicine, 175(8), 581-586. https://doi.org/10.7205/MILMED-D-09-00241
  • Greene, A. K., Austen, W. G., Jr., & May, J. W., Jr. (2007). Flap ischemia after pedicled tissue transfer to a lateral thigh wound: An example of complication assessment using the end result system of E. A. Codman. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 119(5), 1599-1603. https://doi.org/10.1097/01.prs.0000258526.72868.e8
  • Hays, D. W. (1994). Quality improvement and its origin in scientific management. Quality Progress, 27(5), 89-90.
  • Hines, K., Mouchtouris, N., Knightly, J. J., & Harrop, J. (2020). A brief history of quality improvement in health care and spinal surgery. Global Spine Journal, 10(1 Suppl.), 5S-9S. https://doi.org/10.1177/2192568219853529
  • Horner, S. L. (1990). The Health Care Quality Improvement Act of 1986: Its history, provisions, applications and implications. American Journal of Law & Medicine, 16(4), 455-496.
  • Joyner, B. D. (2004). An historical review of graduate medical education and a protocol of Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education compliance. Journal of Urology, 172(1), 34-39. https://doi.org/10.1097/01.ju.0000121804.51403.ef
  • Kalmar, P. (1990). Quality assurance in cardiac surgery: History, preliminaries, practical experience. Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgeon, 38(2), 108-114. https://doi.org/10.1055/s-2007-1014005
  • Kaska, S. C., & Weinstein, J. N. (1998). Ernest Amory Codman, 1869-1940: A pioneer of evidence-based medicine: The end result idea. Spine, 23(5), 629-633. https://doi.org/10.1097/00007632-199803010-00019
  • Kassebaum, D. G. (1992). Origin of the LCME, the AAMC-AMA partnership for accreditation. Academic Medicine, 67(2), 85-87. https://doi.org/10.1097/00001888-199202000-00005
  • Kertzer, D. I., Sigle, W., & White, M. J. (1999). Childhood mortality and quality of care among abandoned children in nineteenth-century Italy. Population Studies, 53(3), 303-315. https://doi.org/10.1080/00324720308085
  • Koyle, M. A., Koyle, L. C. C., & Baker, G. R. (2018). Quality improvement and patient safety: Reality and responsibility from Codman to today. Journal of Pediatric Urology, 14(1), 16-19. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpurol.2017.07.004
  • Kudzma, E. C. (2006). Florence Nightingale and healthcare reform. Nursing Science Quarterly, 19(1), 61-64. https://doi.org/10.1177/0894318405283556
  • Lahidji, B., & Tucker, W. (2016). Continuous quality improvement as a central tenet of TQM: History and current status. Quality Innovation Prosperity, 20(2), 157-168. https://doi.org/10.12776/QIP.V20I2.748
  • Lark, M. E., Kirkpatrick, K., & Chung, K. C. (2018). Patient safety movement: History and future directions. Journal of Hand Surgery: American Volume, 43(2), 174-178. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhsa.2017.11.006
  • Luce, J. M., Bindman, A. B., & Lee, P. R. (1994). A brief history of health care quality assessment and improvement in the United States. Western Journal of Medicine, 160(3), 263-268.
  • Madison, K. M. (2012). From HCQIA to the ACA: The evolution of reporting as a quality improvement tool. Journal of Legal Medicine, 33(1), 63-92. https://doi.org/10.1080/01947648.2012.657600
  • Magnello, M. E. (2012). Victorian statistical graphics and the iconography of Florence Nightingale’s polar area graph. BSHM Bulletin: Journal of the British Society for the History of Mathematics, 27(1), 13-37. https://doi.org/10.1080/17498430.2012.618102
  • McDonald, L. (2010). Florence Nightingale passionate statistician. Journal of Holistic Nursing, 28(1), 92-98. https://doi.org/10.1177/0898010109358769
  • McDonald, L. (2014). Florence Nightingale, statistics and the Crimean War. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A: Statistics in Society, 177(3), 569-586. https://doi.org/10.1111/rssa.12026
  • McDonald, L. (2015). Florence Nightingale: A research-based approach to health, healthcare and hospital safety. In F. Collyer (Ed.), The Palgrave handbook of social theory in health, illness and medicine (pp. 59-74). Palgrave.
  • Meyer, B. C., & Bishop, D. S. (2007). Florence Nightingale: Nineteenth century apostle of quality. Journal of Management History, 13(3), 240-255. https://doi.org/10.1108/17511340710754699
  • O’Kelly, F., Hannick, J. H., Wolfstadt, J. I., Ward, S. E., & Koyle, M. A. (2019). Quality improvement in pediatric urology: A historical perspective on street pumps, puerperal fever, surgical infection, and contemporary methodology. Journal of Pediatric Urology, 15(5), 495-502. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpurol.2019.08.016
  • Osman, M. A., Alam, S., Weerasinghe, K., Taskin, N., & Pauleen, D. (2026). The evolution of quality in healthcare: A diffusion of innovation perspective. Journal of Health Organization and Management, 40(9), 611-628. https://doi.org/10.1108/JHOM-05-2025-0271
  • Ostrow, P. C. (1983). The historical precedents for quality assurance in health care. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 37(1), 23-26. https://doi.org/10.5014/ajot.37.1.23
  • Prislin, M. D., Saultz, J. W., & Geyman, J. P. (2010). The generalist disciplines in American medicine one hundred years following the Flexner report: A case study of unintended consequences and some proposals for post-Flexnerian reform. Academic Medicine, 85(2), 228-235. https://doi.org/10.1097/ACM.0b013e3181c877bf
  • Prochner, L. (1996). Quality of care in historical perspective. Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 11(1), 5-17. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0885-2006(96)90026-5
  • Roberts, J. S., Coale, J. G., & Redman, R. R. (1987). A history of the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Hospitals. JAMA, 258(7), 936-940. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.258.7.936
  • Rohrbasser, A., Harris, J., Mickan, S., Tal, K., & Wong, G. (2018). Quality circles for quality improvement in primary health care: Their origins, spread, effectiveness and lacunae. A scoping review. PLOS ONE, 13(12), Article e0202616. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0202616
  • Russell, T. A., & Ko, C. (2023). History and role of quality accreditation. Clinics in Colon and Rectal Surgery, 36(4), 279-284. https://doi.org/10.1055/s-0043-1761592
  • Santainés-Borredá, E. (2022). Florence Nightingale was a reference hygienist and statistician for Pedro Felipe Monlau. Revista Española de Salud Pública, 96, Article e202202008.
  • Santana, H. T., Costa, M. M. M., Nogueira, M. D. S. P., dos Santos, A. C. R. B., Carvalho, A. A., Morelo, L. T., Ribeiro, C. F. M., de Sousa, F. C., de Moura, H. L. C. A., Barros, L. de S., de Oliveira, L. S. C., & Gonçalves, M. R. S. (2020). The protagonism of the Brazilian Health Regulatory System in the evolution of patient safety in the country: History, dilemmas, and current challenges. Journal of Patient Safety, 16(4), e260-e266. https://doi.org/10.1097/PTS.0000000000000671
  • Schyve, P. M. (2000). The evolution of external quality evaluation: Observations from the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations. International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 12(3), 255-258. https://doi.org/10.1093/intqhc/12.3.255
  • Shafritz, J. M., & Borick, C. P. (2011). Why Florence Nightingale, the famous nurse who pioneered the graphic presentation of statistical data, is the now-forgotten “mother” of program evaluation and PowerPoint® illustrations. In Cases in public policy and administration (pp. 253-259). Routledge.
  • Small, S. D., & Barach, P. (2002). Patient safety and health policy: A history and review. Hematology/Oncology Clinics of North America, 16(6), 1463-1483. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0889-8588(02)00066-7
  • Spiegelhalter, D. J. (1999). Surgical audit: Statistical lessons from Nightingale and Codman. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A: Statistics in Society, 162, 45-58. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-985X.00120
  • Tagge, E. P., Raymond, S. L., McRae, J., Berman, L., Barry, M., Tagge, D. G., Raval, M. V., & Khan, F. A. (2026). Pediatric surgery and healthcare quality: Historical exemplars of quality improvement and the seven basic tools of quality. Journal of Pediatric Surgery, 61(3), Article 162718. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2025.162718
  • Weinmann, C. (1998). Quality improvement in health care: A brief history of the Medicare Peer Review Organization (PRO) initiative. Evaluation & the Health Professions, 21(4), 413-418. https://doi.org/10.1177/016327879802100401
  • Widerquist, J. G. (1997). Sanitary reform and nursing: Edwin Chadwick and Florence Nightingale. Nursing History Review, 5, 149-160. https://doi.org/10.1891/1062-8061.5.1.149
  • Young, H. H. (1982). A brief history of quality assurance and peer review. Professional Psychology, 13(1), 9-13. https://doi.org/10.1037/0735-7028.13.1.9
  • Zrelak, P. A. (2026). Florence Nightingale as a pioneer of applied statistics: Data, visualization, and the foundations of modern healthcare quality improvement. Nursing Outlook, 74(6), Article 102941. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.outlook.2026.102941

Source verification and use of AI. Author names, publication years and DOIs in the reference list were taken from the Web of Science records of the included studies, as were titles, journals, volumes and pages. Claims attributed to sources were checked at abstract level by an independent verifier; full texts were not reviewed, so claims are reported as the titles and abstracts state them, and records without an abstract are cited only for what their titles state. Journal names were normalised from the capitalised Web of Science form, titles were set in sentence case, and obvious export errors in older titles (such as inverted personal names and spurious hyphens) were corrected. AI tools were used to support title and abstract screening, to extract evidence from titles and abstracts into a structured template, to draft the text and to generate the figures. Responsibility for the content rests with the author, Prof. Dr. Mehmet Nurullah Kurutkan.

Data and supplementary material. The full list of the 86 included records, the screening log and the verification report are provided in the supplementary file “HQ_101_supplementary.xlsx”, available from the author on request.

Cite this page (APA 7)

Kurutkan, M. N. (2026, November 18). The History of Quality in Health Care, 1860 to 1960: An Introduction (101). The Health Topics. https://healthtopic.org/topics/history-of-quality-in-health-care-1860-to-1960-an-introduction-101/

Subscribe to the Health Topics Newsletter!

Google reCaptcha: Invalid site key.